Watching
the slick staging of the ‘Renua’ launch was fascinating. Did they get it right?
Time will tell but the media certainly were not buying it. Being fair though, not buying it has much more
currency and is much safer territory than applauding, so we can discount some
of their incredulity. But now that the hype has died down, I ask myself; what
impression am I left with? What does it all add up to? What do they stand for?
Really.
I
am an idealist to the core; so a large part of me was hoping for… hope. I am
still hoping.
Political
brands operate to the same principles as any other brand. Yes the stage is
different, but the principles are the same: how are you positioned v the
competition: what is your core purpose, reason or belief that defines you and
how is that core purpose going to deliver an experience that is relevant,
through branded offerings - in the case of political parties: through it’s
candidates.
At
the core, stereotypical level, Renua would seen to be relatively
undifferentiated. I want to avoid dragging myself into political commentary
here, because it is not my specialty, however their policies confuse me and
leave me with no real sense of raison d'être or distinct positioning. To cap it all they would seem to
be positioning themselves in the most crowded and undifferentiated place: the
centre, or worse still, a less relevant positioning: centre right.
Lucinda
Creighton, the party leader explains, “I consider the old political paradigms of left and
right to be completely redundant now. As far as I’m concerned, the right-wing
model of an overriding free market has completely failed and, equally, I don’t
think I need to explain how socialism has failed in the latter part of the last
century”.
That is
all well and good but it does not excuse a positioning that falls between the
stools and fails to define itself.
I
cannot but help think that in the rush to stick it to Fine Gael; to get in
position for next years elections, they failed to take a step back and develop
a strategic core and positioning for the party. They have failed to connect
this to associated policies and glue it to credible candidates.
Looking
at the branded offerings of Reua, at the top level, the odd couple, politician
Lucinda Creighton and media personality Eddie Hobbs. Two marmite personalities if
ever there was. The 170 declared candidates, a disparate collection with
limited political experience and no cohesion. It is just hard to get a sense of
who Renua really is.
They
are of course new, and learning. And they have formed and launched in less than
a year, with Lucinda having a child in mid flow. Lets see what happens. Mind how
you go though. Whilst you are busy blowing hot air in the centre, the Ross
Alliance are planning to lock horns with a more ‘radical’ offering and Sinn
Fein are strategically positioning themselves in the relevant left, wooing
voters away from a failing Labour. Their eye is on the prize; power on both
sides of the border on the anniversary of the Easter Rising and the birth of
the Irish Republic.